Week Around the Ists

2008blago2.jpg
Image by Lauri Apple/Chicagoist

Email This Entry


Comments (5) [rss]

I cant believe Torontoist is shutting down.

that site has as many posts per day as phillyist has per week.

and as many comments per week as phyllyist gets per year.


im so sad.

Someone at Gothamist apparently made a serious mistake. Torontoist is actually good, has readers, vibrant comments, and oodles of good well written stuff that actually is specific to the city it covers.

Compare it to Phillyist which is not that good, doesn't have readers, has a dearth of comments, and seems to be mostly made up of sparsely posted generic stuff with the majority of the local content being random YouTube videos without any context, adopt the vicious pitbull of the week and a post with a couple of news headlines. It would seem the most logical to go.

Joe Carter:

1. Way to recycle content from your post on PhillyBlogs.

2. Why don't you stick to topics you know about? Oh wait...

JAB

your 2nd point is lame and nonsensical.

Joe's comment is full of knowledge and poignancy.

your comment however is useless.


poor torontoist.

Someone didn't take a good look at the time line. This was where the original content happened.

Really, if you had good compelling content I would check in every day, not every couple of days.

And I do know what I am talking about, I can compare and contrast things. It is something I have been doing since at least as far back grade school.

If you compare and contrast the two it is obvious which one is better, more in touch with the community it supposed to serve and has better quality content. Posting random YouTube videos with out as much as a word of their relevance is just laughable. You used to have more content, but now it might as well be Genericist. How the hell is a top ten list of comic book authors locally relevant. Maybe it would be better to just ditch Phillyist and replace it with Slackerist or something given all your video game and pop culture focus instead of local issues and goings on. You wouldn't even have to make any staff changes!

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

About Phillyist

Phillyist is a website about Philadelphia. More

Editors: Jenn DiSanto, Jillian Ashley Blair Ivey, Andrew Johnston
Publisher: Gothamist

Contribute

Latest Tip:

Yes, the Red Cross is probably where you want to go to find out how to contribute to disaster relief
[more]

Latest Photo:

Recent Comments

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Phillyist.

All Our RSS